Friday, May 3, 2024
HomeNews'Padmavati' row 'dangerous' in the foreign film world's eyes

‘Padmavati’ row ‘dangerous’ in the foreign film world’s eyes

Published on

They don’t know fact from fiction about fabled Rajput queen Padmavati, but the uproar over Sanjay Leela Bhansali’s “Padmavati” has made visiting international movie talent here sit up and take note of how “autocratic” and “dangerous” voices and actions are infringing on freedom of expression in India’s film industry.

Iranian filmmaker Majid Majidi and Toronto International Film Festival (TIFF) artistic director Cameron Bailey, who were at the just-concluded 48th International Film Festival of India (IFFI), were vocal in their support for Bhansali.

“Artistes face this kind of situations because of the talent and desire they have. That extends to filmmakers too. They should not stop innovation in their work because of adverse conditions,” Majidi said on the opening day of the festival.

He was among a string of artistes and filmmakers who visited IFFI, which itself was caught in a controversy over the exclusion of two films — “S. Durga” and “Nude” — from its Indian Panorama section. The brouhaha over these and “Padmavati” — which is under attack for alleged distortion of facts — became a crucial talking point throughout the fest.

Michael J. Werner, a film and media strategic consultant who attended the Film Bazaar here, told IANS: “I think it is a dangerous trend because you shouldn’t have a government dictating history. What is happening with this particular movie (‘Padmavati’) seems to be a minister or a department or a state saying that we don’t accept that representation of history.

“I don’t know whether it is factual or not, but it is still a kind of an autocratic response.”

See also  Prince Narula to make fiction TV debut as wrestler

“Padmavati”, which sets out to tell the tale of the valour and courage of Rani Padmavati, whose historicity is in doubt, has been under the scanner since its shoot began. Its National Award-winning director was assaulted and the set vandalised in Jaipur by Rajput organisation Karni Sena over the conjecture that the movie will feature intimate scenes between the characters of Padmavati and the invader Alauddin Khilji.

Thereafter, the Karni Sena has continued its protest and has been intense in its effort to stall the film’s release, which has been deferred from its original December 1 date as of now.

There were threats to burn down theatres if the film was released and a Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) leader announced a reward of Rs 10 crore for beheading Bhansali and the movie’s lead actress, Deepika Padukone.

In the midst of this, “Padmavati” got a go-ahead from the British Board of Film Classification (BBFC) for release. But the makers are waiting for a decision by India’s censor board.

French producer Ilann Girard feels a film shouldn’t be held hostage by any conflict.

“I have been watching things on television and asking my Indian friends about the situation. I understand it touches some cultural element about a female character who is seen as a very important symbolic figure for Hindus,” Girard, Managing Director of Online Film Financing (OLFI), told IANS.

Girard, who was visiting India for the third time, didn’t want to pass any judgment as it’s an “Indian topic”, but said: “My perception is that film and the cultural industry should not be taken hostage of the conflicts.”

See also 

Narrating his own struggle with freedom of expression, he said: “I have produced a film in Israel about the war in Lebanon, and we are facing some embargo from filmmakers trying to pressurise film festivals not to take our movie. I think it is a wrong thing to do. Because, on the contrary, the film explains the situation… Filmmakers should remain free to tell the story that they want.”

TIFF’s Bailey said people must wait for censor clearance before drawing assumptions and conclusions.

“One of the small mercies with censor authorities is that they actually do watch the film before they pass judgment. So one hopes that anyone who hears about a film that they think that they might have an objection to, should first watch the film,” Bailey told IANS.

Bailey feels the film should be given a “benefit of doubt before passing judgment”.

“We can all have differences of opinion with any art form, but I think we live in a better world where we wait to actually see what the film is before we pass judgment. Also, we accept that other people have different responses to that. What I might not like to see on-screen, some others might. That doesn’t mean I should prevent that person from seeing it.”

Mike Dougherty from Radiant Films International, a worldwide distribution company, feels the controversy is unfortunate for “the filmmakers and for the audiences eager to see the film”.

He, however, said the row will perhaps draw more eyeballs to the movie across the world.

“The issues causing unrest around ‘Padmavati’ here in India are not known in other parts of the world. If anything, I think controversies like this just increase a film’s profile and its value internationally, making people more eager to see what the uproar is about,” Dougherty added.

See also  'Tum Bin 2' not a sequel: Anubhav Sinha

As dark clouds still loom over the future of “Padmavati”, Ana Tiwary, a Sydney-based producer-director of Indivisual Films, hopes the controversy will die down soon.

(Sugandha Rawal’s trip to Goa was at the invitation of IFFI organisers. She can be contacted at [email protected])

By Sugandha Rawal

Follow Hamara Photos on Google News

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Follow Hamara Photos on Google News

Latest articles

More like this

Britney Spears Reflects on Her Split with Sam Asghari

Britney Spears reveals her emotions surrounding her breakup with long-time partner Sam Asghari.

Lizzo Refutes Sexual Harassment Accusations Made By Former Dancers

Lizzo vehemently denies sexual harassment allegations laid by her erstwhile dancers. She refuted these accusations, defending her character and principles strongly.

Prospective Delay of ‘Dune: Part Two’ as Hollywood Strikes Grow More Intense

'Dune: Part Two', the anticipated sequel, faces potential indefinite delay amidst amplified Hollywood strikes, pandemic-induced economic strain, and theatre chain's financial troubles.

Angelina Jolie’s Ex-Business Files Legal Action against Bradd Pitt’s Associates

As the vineyard dispute intensifies, Angelina Jolie's ex-company Nouvel files a legal action against Brad Pitt's associates. The battle over the French winery, Chateau Miraval, unfolds a new drama in their post-marital saga.

Legal Storm Brews Over Kanye West’s Donda Academy Amidst Allegations of Unsafe Conditions

Rapper Kanye West is embroiled in a lawsuit filed by a former gym teacher of Donda Academy, alleging wrongful termination and violation of safety and labor codes due to unsafe conditions.

Madonna revived with an emergency injection

Madonna experienced septic shock from a severe bacterial infection, postponing her tour. She's steadily recovering with the support of her loved ones.